Best and Worst Toyota Highlander Years With Alternatives
If you want to know which Toyota Highlander years to avoid and which years are safe to buy, read this comprehensive guide till the end.
This Best and Worst Toyota Highlander Years review is based on authentic data. Our team of automotive experts has spent 87 hours meticulously collecting real-life data on Toyota Highlander models through extensive research, user surveys, and analysis of owner-reported experiences to provide accurate and comprehensive insights for our article.
Within the automotive market, the midsize SUV segment stands as a fiercely competitive arena. For those seeking a used midsize SUV offering exceptional utility, longevity, and reliability, the Toyota Highlander is a wonderful choice.
Numerous Highlander owners attest to the vehicle’s remarkable longevity, with many effortlessly surpassing the 200,000-mile mark.
Remarkable anecdotes even abound of Highlanders exceeding 350,000 to 500,000 miles, with only minor part replacements. Paired with Toyota’s renowned reputation for reliability and durability.
Delving into the realm of used Toyota Highlanders, discerning buyers may wonder: which model years offer the utmost reliability, and which generation has the best and worst years?
Let’s dig in to find out:
Overall Best and Worst Toyota Highlander Years
Toyota Highlander Year | Key Features | Common Issues |
Best Year (2020) | Comprehensive driver assistance features, spacious interior, and an advanced infotainment system | Infotainment system issues, mechanical problems |
Worst Year (2008) | Numerous engine-related problems, brake issues | Engine knocking, rattling noise on startup, brake malfunctions |
Toyota Highlander Generations
Years | Generations |
---|---|
2001-2007 | Toyota Highlander (XU20, 1st generation) |
2008-2013 | Toyota Highlander (XU40, 2nd generation) |
2014-2019 | Toyota Highlander (XU50, 3rd generation) |
2020-Present | Toyota Highlander (XU70, 4th generation) |
The above-mentioned table shows four different Toyota Highlander generations, offering a comprehensive overview of the model’s evolutionary trajectory.
Within each generation lie pivotal transformations encompassing design, functionality, and technological advancements, all of which wield considerable influence over prospective buyers’ purchasing deliberations.
Following is a list of sources and factors we used to gather our data:
- Owner-reported reliability (surveys)
- Annual maintenance costs
- Rating for Safety
- Consumer Reports
- NHTSA investigations and complaints
- Edmunds owner ratings
- JD Power owner ratings
- Kelley’s Blue Book owner ratings
- Vehicle history owner ratings
- com owner ratings
Best, Neutral, and Poor Years of Toyota Highlander
Generations | Best | Normal | Poor | Best Features | Cons |
1st (2001-2007) | 2003 2004 2005 2006 | 2002 | 2001 2007 | Exceptional reliability, comfortable ride, and generous cargo space | Transmission problems, air conditioning failures |
2nd (2008-2013) | 2009 2011 2012 2013 | 2010 | 2008 | Smooth ride, strong engine options, ample interior space | Engine issues, interior electronics malfunctions |
3rd (2014-2019) | 2014 2016 2017 2018 | 2015 | 2019 | Upscale interior, advanced safety features, fuel efficiency | Transmission failures, infotainment glitches |
4th (2020-current) | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 2023 | Comprehensive driver assistance features, spacious interior | Infotainment system issues, mechanical problems |
These categorizations stem from extensive research spanning numerous hours, meticulously analyzing a plethora of factors.
These include owner-reported reliability scores, annual maintenance costs, safety ratings, Consumer Reports reliability, and owner satisfaction scores, NHTSA recalls, investigations, complaints, and owner ratings from prominent sources such as Edmunds, JD Power, Kelley’s Blue Book (KBB), VehicleHistory, and Cars.com.
Various factors may contribute to the rankings’ fluctuations. For instance, a heightened frequency of NHTSA recalls could signal diminished reliability, consequently exerting downward pressure on a model year’s overall score.
Here are the detailed reviews and scores:
Toyota Highlander 1st Generation: Best and Worst Years (2001–2007)
Best Years: 2003, 2004, 20 05, 2006
These years marked the pinnacle of the first generation, characterized by exceptional reliability, a plush ride, and expansive cargo capacity.
Notably, the introduction of the 3.3-liter V6 engine in 2004 significantly bolstered power output, augmenting towing capabilities while preserving fuel efficiency.
Moreover, advancements in safety features during this period, including sophisticated airbag systems and optional stability control, further enhanced the Highlander’s appeal.
Normal Year: 2002
The 2002 model exhibited commendable reliability and performance. However, minor issues related to coolant leaks and oxygen sensor failures within the engine prevented it from retaining its position as the best.
Despite these minor setbacks, its spacious interior and comfortable ride maintained its appeal.
Poor Years: 2001–2007
The inaugural 2001 model encountered several hurdles, including transmission malfunctions and air conditioning system failures.
These challenges contributed to an uptick in owner-reported issues, tarnishing its initial reputation.
Similarly, the 2007 model, serving as the final iteration of this generation, garnered criticism for lackluster handling and substandard interior quality, marking a disappointing conclusion to an otherwise commendable era.
Check carcomplaints for the 2007 model.
Check NHTSA complaints for the years 2001 and 2007
Toyota Highlander 2nd Generation: Best and Worst Years (2008–2013)
Best Years: 2009, 2011, 2012
The years 2009, 2011, and 2012 offered spacious comfort with their three-row seating variants targeting families.
Distinguishing features of these models include the integration of a robust 3.5-liter V6 engine, delivering a harmonious blend of power and fuel efficiency.
Augmented safety attributes such as traction control enhancements and superior crash safety ratings further enhance their allure.
2009 Toyota Highlander Reviews
The 2009 Toyota Highlander remains a top contender, offering a balance of maneuverability, power, and fuel efficiency, making it an excellent choice for various needs.
Recognized as an IIHS “Top Safety Pick,” the 2009 Highlander prioritizes safety, making it particularly suitable for family use.
While there were minimal changes for this model year, the addition of a new 2.7-liter four-cylinder engine to the base two-wheel drive trim provides buyers with more options.
- Edmunds: 4.6/5.0
- Kelley Blue Book: 4.6/5.0
- JD Power: 85/100
An Edmunds review of the 2009 Highlander reflects its acclaim:
“After having researched extensively and test-driven the Honda Pilot, Mitsubishi Outlander, Ford Edge, and the new Equinox, I repeatedly returned to the Highlander and bought one a few weeks ago. I cannot express how impressed I am with Highlander! The ride is extraordinarily comfortable, quiet, and smooth. The interior is extremely roomy, well-designed, and functional.“
2011 and 2012 Toyota Highlander Reviews
In 2011, the Highlander underwent a modest refresh, featuring a redesigned exterior and updated standard features.
Notable additions included a 50/50 split-folding third-row seat and rear climate controls for the base and SE trims.
However, the Sport trim was discontinued for this model year.
The 2012 Highlander retained the reliability and quality of its predecessor, solidifying its reputation as a top performer in its segment.
2012 Highlander:
- Edmunds: 4.5/5.0
- Kelley Blue Book: 4.6/5.0
- JD Power: 84/100
2011 Highlander:
- Edmunds: 4.6/5.0
- Kelley Blue Book: 4.6/5.0
- JD Power: 82/100
An Edmunds review of the 2012 Highlander highlights its impressive performance and capabilities:
“This is a great car; it gives a nice ride, and its performance is also good. I need to watch my speed as it goes faster than it feels, so I use the cruise control on highways. We climbed Mount Washington in New Hampshire and came down the mountain using hill assist and never had to use the brakes for the whole decline of the mountain.
Another Edmunds review of the 2011 Highlander praises its updated styling and technological features:
“Having traded in our ’04 Camry, this Highlander is our 5th Toyota. The styling for 2011 is much improved over the ’08-’10 version and can actually be called a “looker.” After two weeks of owning it, I’ve had two strangers stop me and ask about it. Having a great time with the navigation system, the Bluetooth phone set up, and the entertainment system.”
Normal Years: 2013
The 2013 iteration emerges as a neutral contender within this spectrum. While it maintains a satisfactory level of reliability and interior spaciousness, it fails to outshine its predecessors in many ways, including seating comfort and engine performance.
Primary deterrents to its elevation include minor glitches associated with electric power steering and intermittent transmission irregularities, detracting from its overall rating.
Poor Years: 2008 and 2010
2008 and 2010 stand out as less favorable options within this spectrum.
The 2008 model, initiating the second generation, grappled with engine-related concerns, notably excessive oil consumption.
Additionally, reports surfaced regarding malfunctioning interior electronics, encompassing navigation systems and climate control functionalities.
Meanwhile, the 2010 rendition echoed similar tribulations, compounded by premature brake deterioration and compromised body integrity.
Check car complaints for 2008 and complaints for 2010 models.
Check NHTSA complaints for the years 2008 and 2010
Recommended Read: Best and Worst Toyota Sequoia models
Toyota Highlander 3rd Generation: Best and Worst Years (2014–2021)
The advent of the third-generation Highlander in 2014 heralded a shift towards a more luxurious ambiance, heightened power, and advanced safety provisions.
Best Years: 2014, 2016, 2017, and 2018
These years distinguished themselves through impeccable reliability, enhanced performance, and an elevated standard of interior opulence.
The integration of a more efficient transmission bolstered fuel economy, while tech features within the Highlander received appreciation for their user-friendly nature.
Notably, safety enhancements were prominent, with Toyota’s Safety Sense package incorporating pre-collision and lane departure warnings.
2016 Toyota Highlander Review
The 2016 Toyota Highlander emerges as a prime choice for families seeking a three-row crossover, characterized by its comfortable ride, refined interior, and robust reliability.
While no significant upgrades were implemented for the 2016 model year, it stands out as one of the least problematic iterations of the third generation. Minor enhancements include the standardization of a towing package across all V6 models.
According to expert evaluations,
- Edmunds: 4.3/5.0
- Kelley Blue Book: 4.4/5.0
- JD Power: 83/100
In an Edmunds review of the 2016 Highlander, the following observations were made:
“Pros: rock solid look, feel, and handling. Calm-instilling, smooth, quiet ride. Sensible, simple, intuitive controls. Luxury cars look, feel, and perform at a below-luxury price and with lower-cost regular fuel! Safe, effective all-wheel drive and active safety systems. Cons: smaller than ideal cargo space. Very tight third row—for young children or emergencies, short trips only.”
2014 Toyota Highlander Reviews
The 2014 Toyota Highlander marks the inauguration of the third generation, presenting a comprehensive redesign both internally and externally.
Offering an array of trim levels and drivetrain options, it signifies a notable advancement in the Highlander lineage.
Key enhancements include upgraded interior craftsmanship, the option for seating up to eight passengers, a height-adjustable power liftgate, and the incorporation of a six-speed automatic transmission for V6-equipped models.
Moreover, the 2014 Highlander introduced innovative features such as Driver Easy Speak, utilizing the vehicle’s built-in microphone to amplify the driver’s voice through the rear speakers.
Critical evaluations are as follows:
- Edmunds: 4.4/5.0
- Kelley Blue Book: 4.4/5.0
- JD Power: 81/100
In an Edmunds review of the 2014 Highlander, an owner shared the following insights:
“I purchased the 2014 Highlander after owning a 2006 model for eight years and 130K miles with minimal problems. The 2006 was a hybrid, and I miss the better MPG, but without a tax credit, I couldn’t justify the additional $12K (2014 hybrids only come in the highest trim levels). I’m 6’3, and the new model is just big enough inside to sleep comfortably with the second and third rows down.
Normal Years: 2015
The 2015 Highlander maintained the established benchmark set by its predecessor without introducing notable advancements or significant issues.
However, sporadic reports of infotainment system glitches and a marginally stiffer ride quality marred its otherwise commendable reputation.
2015 Toyota Highlander Reviews
The 2015 Toyota Highlander witnessed mixed reviews, with notable complaints surrounding comfort and unexpected sunroof incidents.
Primary owners have issues with uncomfortable seating, with some labeling them as the most uncomfortable they’ve encountered. Another prevalent issue involved instances of the sunroof spontaneously shattering, causing alarm among occupants. Reports described a loud noise followed by glass fragments scattering above passengers.
Critical evaluations are as follows:
- CarComplaints.com: 83 complaints
- CarProblemZoo.com: 194 problems
Commonly reported problems encompass:
- Uncomfortable seats
- Excessive wind noise
- Sunroof explosion
- Audio system settings are resetting intermittently.
Poor Years: 2019
The 2019 model year stands out as the least favorable within this range. Despite boasting a premium interior and an array of standard safety features, criticisms arose regarding its comparatively lackluster driving dynamics.
Reported issues with the transmission, including abrupt shifts and occasional response delays, contributed to its diminished ranking.
2019 Toyota Highlander Reviews
The 2019 Toyota Highlander faced significant complaints about power loss and stalling while in operation, often attributed to fuel pump failures.
Toyota initiated two recalls for the 2019 Highlander due to these fuel pump issues.
Owners recounted instances of power loss while driving, resulting in deceleration and, in some cases, complete stalls.
This posed safety risks, as reported incidents occurred even at highway speeds, necessitating sudden stops.
Multiple warning lights illuminated during these episodes, prompting owners to seek immediate inspection, revealing fuel pump malfunctions.
Key details are as follows:
- CarComplaints.com: 29 complaints
- CarProblemZoo.com: 247 problems
Commonly reported issues include:
- Dashboard defects
- Stalling and loss of power
- Navigation system voice guidance malfunction
- Bluetooth connectivity issues
Check NHTSA complaints for the year 2019
Recommended Read: Best and Worst Toyota Tacoma models
Toyota Highlander 4th Generation: Best and Worst Years (2020-Present)
Best Year: 2020
The 2020 model year established a benchmark for the new generation, integrating a comprehensive array of driver assistance technologies, an opulent and spacious interior, and a robust V6 engine.
Its redesign introduced a sleeker exterior and a quieter cabin, enhancing its overall appeal. Notably, the debut of the Highlander Hybrid variant, with its remarkable fuel efficiency, distinguished the 2020 model.
2020 Toyota Highlander Reviews
The 2020 Toyota Highlander underwent a significant overhaul, emerging with a fresh design, enhanced features, improved interior space, and Toyota’s latest safety and infotainment technologies.
This model had the fewest complaints ever registered.
Equipped with a robust 295-horsepower 3.5-liter V-6 engine and an eight-speed automatic transmission available in both front-wheel and all-wheel drive configurations, the Highlander delivers potent performance.
Its commendable safety ratings, exceptional comfort, and above-average fuel efficiency further elevate its appeal.
- Edmunds: 3.8/5.0
- Kelley Blue Book: 4.3/5.0
- JD Power: 82/100
In an Edmunds review of the 2020 Highlander, it was noted:
“Test drove the 2020 Limited. The V-6 engine was responsive, and the ride was very quiet. Very good standard technology and driving safety packages. The interior had quality materials and a good fit and finish. Second-row captain’s chair seats are comfortable with plenty of room behind the first row; third-row seats are useless except for small children, which you would want in the second row.
Normal Year: 2021
While the 2021 Highlander maintained its competitive edge in the midsize SUV segment, it didn’t significantly surpass its predecessor, the 2020 model.
Despite commendable safety ratings and a comfortable interior, criticism arose regarding the finicky nature of the infotainment system and a relatively higher starting price, leading to its categorization as neutral.
The models this year weren’t bad, but they weren’t able to catch up to their predecessors in terms of performance.
Poor Years: 2022, 2023
Although recent, the 2022 and 2023 model years encountered some scrutiny. Owners reported issues with the infotainment system, including screen freezing and spontaneous system reboots.
Additionally, minor mechanical concerns related to the braking system and transmission surfaced, contributing to their classification as “poor” years.
Check NHTSA complaints for the years 2022 and 2023
Recommended Read: Best and Worst Toyota RAV4 models
Best Alternatives to the Toyota Highlander
Make & Model | Score | MSRP | Fuel Economy (MPG) | Best Features |
Kia Telluride | 8.6 | $33,390 – $45,190 | City: 19 – 20 /Highway: 24 – 26 | Spacious interior, advanced tech features |
Ford Palisade | 8.6 | $33,600 – $48,990 | City: 19 / Highway: 27 | Smooth ride, generous cargo space |
Honda Passport | 8.4 | $37,870 – $45,430 | City: 19 – 20 /Highway: 24 – 25 | Strong engine performance, off-road capability |
Mazda CX-9 | 8.4 | $35,280 – $47,210 | City: 20 / Highway: 26 | Upscale interior, engaging driving dynamics |
Hyundai Santa Fe | 8.3 | $27,200 – $43,110 | City: 21 – 25 / Highway: 25 – 28 | User-friendly infotainment, comfortable seats |
Chevrolet Traverse | 8.3 | $33,700 – $53,400 | City: 17 – 18 / Highway: 25 – 27 | Ample cargo space, smooth ride |
Honda Pilot | 8.3 | $38,080 – $51,870 | City: 19 – 20 /Highway: 26 – 27 | Versatile interior, strong safety features |
Jeep Grand Cherokee | 8.3 | $39,000 – $61,675 | City: 14 – 19 /Highway: 22 – 26 | Off-road capability, upscale cabin |
Buick Enclave | 8.1 | $42,800 – $57,100 | City: 17 – 18 /Highway: 25 -26 | Quiet and comfortable ride, upscale interior |
Dodge Durango | 8.0 | $36,995 – $68,195 | City: 13 – 19 /Highway: 19 – 26 | Powerful engine options, towing capability |
Volkswagen Atlas | 8.0 | $33,635 – $51,505 | City: 17 – 21 /Highway: 23 – 25 | Spacious interior, smooth ride |
Subaru Ascent | 8.0 | $32,295 – $45,445 | City: 20 – 21 /Highway: 26 – 27 | Standard all-wheel drive, advanced safety features |
Kia Sorento | 8.0 | $29,590 – $43,190 | City: 21 – 24 /Highway: 25 – 29 | Intuitive infotainment system, comfortable ride |
Toyota Highlander | 7.9 | $35,405 – $49,510 | City: 20 – 21 /Highway: 27 – 29 | Smooth ride, Toyota’s legendary reliability |
Nissan Murano | 7.7 | $33,310 – $46,560 | City: 20Highway: 28 | Comfortable seats, upscale cabin |
Ford Explorer | 7.7 | $33,745 – $55,995 | City: 16 – 27 /Highway: 23 – 28 | Potent engine options, ample cargo space |
GMC Acadia | 7.5 | $34,800 – $48,600 | City: 19 – 22 /Highway: 26 – 29 | Smooth handling, user-friendly infotainment |
Chevrolet Blazer | 7.3 | $33,400 – $44,000 | City: 19 – 22 /Highway: 26 – 29 | Sporty exterior design, strong engine options |
Toyota 4Runner | 7.1 | $37,605 – $52,420 | City: 16 / Highway: 19 | Off-road capability, rugged durability |
Ford Edge | NA | $36,145 – $44,945 | City: 19 – 21 /Highway: 25 – 28 | Sporty handling, comfortable ride |
Jeep Grand Cherokee L | NA | $40,325 – $62,300 | City: 18 – 19 /Highway: 25 – 26 | Luxurious interior, advanced technology |
Nissan Pathfinder | NA | $34,640 – $49,040 | City: 20 – 21 /Highway: 25 – 27 | Comfortable seating, versatile cargo space |
Common Toyota Highlander problems
Defective Airbags (2013, 2016, and 2020 Models):
Certain Highlander models experienced airbag malfunctions, failing to deploy during collisions. Notably, over 3,300 Highlander and Highlander Hybrids from 2020 were recalled due to defective trim covers potentially obstructing seat-mounted side airbag deployment.
Head Gasket and Oxygen Sensor Failure (2001–2007 Models):
Reports of overheating engines attributed to blown head gaskets and faulty oxygen sensors resulted in engine misfires and rough idling.
Interior Problems (2015 and 2008 Models):
The 2015 Highlander garnered complaints about uncomfortable seats back pain on long drives and issues with the audio system. Similarly, the 2008 model faced problems with a randomly activating panic alarm and a defective CD player.
Oil Leaks and Loss of Oil Pressure (2005–2013 Models):
Owners observed engine oil puddles and noticed burning oil smells inside the cabin, often stemming from a faulty variable valve timing-intelligent (VVT-i) gear and ruptured oil cooler lines.
Ruptured Oil Lines (2005–2013 Models):
Ruptured oil lines led to engine failure due to oil loss, necessitating costly repairs.
Disconnected Air Filter Housing Hose (2001–2011 Models):
This issue impacted the vehicle’s air-fuel ratio, causing engine hesitation, stalling, or rough idling.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the key differences between Toyota Highlander trims?
Toyota Highlander trims vary in features such as engine options, seating capacity, technology packages, and interior amenities. Higher trims often offer more advanced safety features, premium materials, and additional comfort options compared to base models.
How does the Toyota Highlander perform in terms of fuel efficiency?
Generally, Highlander models equipped with hybrid powertrains offer better fuel economy compared to those with traditional gasoline engines.
What are the common maintenance tasks for a Toyota Highlander?
Routine maintenance for a Toyota Highlander includes oil changes, tire rotations, brake inspections, fluid checks, and periodic inspections of the vehicle’s mechanical components.
Is the Toyota Highlander a good choice for families?
The Toyota Highlander is widely regarded as a family-friendly SUV due to its spacious interior, versatile seating configurations, advanced safety features, and smooth ride quality.
Does the Toyota Highlander have towing capabilities?
The Toyota Highlander is capable of towing moderate loads, especially when equipped with the available towing package and a V6 engine.
How does the Toyota Highlander perform in terms of safety ratings?
The Toyota Highlander typically receives high safety ratings from organizations such as the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) and the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS).
What features are available in the Toyota Highlander?
The Toyota Highlander offers a range of technology features, including touchscreen infotainment systems, smartphone integration (Apple CarPlay, Android Auto), navigation systems, premium audio systems, wireless charging, and advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS) such as blind-spot monitoring and rear cross-traffic alert.